Payhip is cheaper than Gumroad at every sales volume when you compare platform charges alone. Payhip Free takes 5% and nothing else, while Gumroad takes 10% plus $0.50 on each direct sale. On $2,000 a month in $50 orders that is $100 against $220. Gumroad earns its higher price in two places only: it handles sales tax for you and it has a marketplace, Discover, that can send buyers at a 30% rate.
Gumroad's figures were read from its pricing page and help centre on 4 September 2026. Payhip's pricing page blocks automated reads, so its rates come from an archived copy dated 5 August 2026. Confirm both on the vendor's page before you decide. Card processing is excluded throughout so the two are compared like for like.
Payhip vs Gumroad at a glance
| Item | Gumroad | Payhip |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $0 a month | $0 a month (Free plan) |
| Platform fee, own traffic | 10% + $0.50 per sale | 5% on Free, 2% on Plus, 0% on Pro |
| Paid plans | None | Plus $29 a month, Pro $99 a month |
| Marketplace | Discover, 30% per sale | No buyer-sending marketplace |
| Best for | First product, no setup, tax handled | Sellers who want a lower rate as sales grow |
The structural difference matters more than any single rate. Gumroad has one price, so the percentage never falls. Payhip has plans, so a growing seller can pay a monthly amount to cut the rate. Our Gumroad fee breakdown shows the same trap from Gumroad's side.
What each costs at $500, $2,000 and $10,000 a month
Assuming a $50 average order, which only matters for Gumroad's flat $0.50.
| Monthly sales | Gumroad direct | Gumroad Discover | Payhip Free | Payhip Plus | Payhip Pro |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | $55 | $150 | $25 | $39 | $99 |
| $2,000 | $220 | $600 | $100 | $69 | $99 |
| $10,000 | $1,100 | $3,000 | $500 | $229 | $99 |
Read the table by volume. Below about $970 a month Payhip Free is the cheapest Payhip plan. Between roughly $970 and $3,500, Plus wins. Above $3,500, Pro at a flat $99 is cheapest, and by $10,000 a month it saves $1,001 against Gumroad. Pro at $99 is a plan to grow into, which is why Free exists.
Where Gumroad is still the better pick
You want sales tax handled
Gumroad states in its terms that it acts as the seller of record, which is how it collects and remits tax on your behalf. For a first-time seller with buyers in several states and countries, that is real work you do not do. It is the main reason Gumroad's higher fee is defensible. Check Gumroad's own pricing page and terms for the current wording.
You have no audience and want a marketplace
Discover can introduce you to buyers you did not bring. You pay 30% on those sales, so a $50 product leaves you $35 before processing. If the alternative is no sale at all, that can be worth it. If you drive your own traffic, link every product directly and pay the 10% rate instead.
Where Payhip wins
It wins on cost for anyone who sends their own buyers: a newsletter, social audience or search traffic. A seller doing $2,000 a month on direct links keeps $120 more each month on Payhip Free, or $151 more on Plus, which is $1,440 to $1,810 a year. It also gives you a clean upgrade path. You do not change platforms when volume grows, you change plan.
A worked example: a template seller
A designer sells Notion and Figma templates at $25 each and does 80 sales a month, $2,000 in revenue. The flat $0.50 on Gumroad is 2 points of a $25 sale, so the effective rate is 12%: 80 times $0.50 is $40 plus $200 in percentage, $240. On Payhip Free the same month costs $100. Moving saves $140 a month, $1,680 a year, with no change to the product or the price. That is the cost of choosing the first platform you heard of.
What if you sell services, not downloads
Both tools are checkouts. They process a payment for a file. A freelancer selling a logo, an edit or an audit needs buyers to find a page, compare tiers and understand the scope before paying, and neither Gumroad nor Payhip is built for search traffic to land on a service. For that job a ranked gig page does what a checkout does not. Our Gumroad alternatives comparison prices ten options at three volumes, and our plans start at $9 a month with an 8% take, falling to 3% at the top tier. The digital products platform guide covers downloads in more depth.
Payhip vs Gumroad questions
Is Payhip cheaper than Gumroad?
Yes. Payhip Free takes 5% against Gumroad's 10% plus $0.50, so it costs less from the first dollar. At $2,000 a month in $50 orders the platform charge is $100 against $220. Payhip's paid plans cut the rate further as sales grow.
Does Gumroad take a percentage of every sale?
Yes. Gumroad charges 10% plus $0.50 on direct sales and 30% on sales that arrive through its Discover marketplace. There is no monthly fee and no paid plan that lowers the percentage, so the cost rises in step with your revenue.
Which is better for a first product?
Gumroad if you want tax handled and almost no setup, Payhip if you expect to pass $320 a month in sales soon and would rather start on the cheaper rate. At that volume Payhip Plus already costs less than Gumroad direct.
The short version
For downloads sold to your own audience, start on Payhip. For a first product with tax handled and no audience yet, Gumroad is fine and costs more. For services, neither is the right tool. If you sell packaged work, you can start your gig page and let buyers order from tiers you set.